Demotech urges advisory loss costs split into three components

Image
Demotech urges advisory loss costs split into three components

COLUMBUS -- November 19, 2026 -- Demotech, Inc. President Joe Petrelli urged regulators at the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Summer National Meeting to have advisory organizations present advisory loss costs as the sum of three components. Demotech says the current formula, claim frequency multiplied by claim cost, has not been revised in four decades.

By our calculation, the proposal raises the number of published inputs from two to six: a frequency and a cost for each of three claim categories. Petrelli said the dollar amount of a loss cost would not change.

Petrelli names Verisk, AAIS and NCCI as the organizations that could supply the breakdown

The NAIC held its 20th Summer National Meeting from Aug. 11-14, 2026, in Columbus, Ohio, in a hybrid format. Petrelli named Verisk (Insurance Services Office), the American Association of Insurance Services and the National Council on Compensation Insurance as advisory organizations that produce loss costs. He said they can help regulators, insurers and consumers identify the drivers of claim frequency, claim severity and loss adjustment expenses behind loss cost revisions.

The three categories he proposes are claims closed without payment, litigated claims and non-litigated claims. Each would carry its own frequency and cost, and the three products would be added to give the aggregate loss cost.

Demotech says the mid-1980s formula assumed balance between settled and litigated claims

Until the mid-1980s, advisory organizations published advisory rates and premiums that included corporate expenses and a pre-tax profit provision. Carriers often deviated from them, mostly downward. Advisory loss costs, the average loss per policyholder without expenses or profit provision, then became the norm. They are trended for inflation and adjusted for expected changes in claim frequency.

Demotech says the formula implicitly assumed an equilibrium between claims reported by and settled with policyholders and claims litigated and negotiated with plaintiff firms. It says that balance no longer holds. It cites billboard, TV and radio advertising, third-party litigation funding, tech-enabled litigation instigation, alternative business structures and managed services organizations. Demotech says its postmortem on failed carriers led to a research project that identified the tech-enabled model.

Petrelli cites a changed claim mix in Schedule P data over 10 years

Petrelli describes a second rationale as "claim transitioning." Using industry aggregate reported claim counts from Schedule P, Part 5 of the NAIC annual statement, he said the shares of claims closed without indemnity, closed with indemnity and outstanding had changed over the most recent 10 years. The release gives no figures for that shift.

Demotech says a three-part format would let stakeholders separate and investigate each component. Under the current two-factor format, a revision in a loss cost cannot be attributed to litigated claims specifically. Under the proposed format, regulators and legislators could see the impact of litigation on the cost of insurance, according to Demotech.

Petrelli shared his views with several commissioners and other leaders at state departments of insurance during the Columbus meeting.

Published by:
fairsonline_team
Target market(s)
News Type