UNITED STATES -- November 21, 2026 -- A Circana client cut out-of-stocks (OOS) in the diaper category by 63% and recaptured $1.6 million in lost sales, according to a guidance paper by Circana supply chain executives Tom Elliot and Nicola Webb. Circana says its clients typically recover 5% to 8% of sales lost to OOS, which works out to $5 million to $8 million for every $100 million lost, by our calculation.
The authors say the diaper result came from identifying where and which type of OOS was occurring, then applying a separate fix to each. They name four types: shelf out-of-stock, distribution voids, phantom inventory and low shelf on hand. Each has a different cause, data signature, owner and fix, they write.
Data granularity decides whether the types can be told apart. Circana says diagnosis needs store, item and day data. In weekly or chain-level views, a phantom inventory problem in one store disappears inside a regional average, and a distribution void can look like low velocity at banner level.
Misdiagnosis carries a cost for both sides, the authors say. A retailer that sees repeated gaps may order more stock, although the cause was a manufacturer that could not supply the product. Shoppers may switch brands or stores.
Manufacturers have little shelf visibility once product leaves their trucks. The paper cites a broker who visits three stores in a 2,000-store chain; that sample covers 0.15% of the network, by our calculation. Retailers, in turn, may not know a supplier is capacity-constrained or is shorting one account to serve another.
For triage, Circana recommends four steps: quantify lost sales by store, item and OOS type; rank by total lost-sales value; assign each issue to its owner; apply the type-specific fix and monitor for recurrence.
Circana did not disclose the client's name, the baseline OOS rate or the period over which the 63% reduction was achieved.