LAKE GENEVA -- November 19, 2026 -- Insurance and claim spending at the 10 largest U.S. trucking companies rose by more than 50 percent from 2021 through 2025, according to a review of their public financial information presented at The Machinery Haulers Association's 2026 Safety and Security Conference. By our calculation, that means at least $150 of spending in 2025 for every $100 in 2021, while profitability fell "dramatically" over the same period, according to the presenter's analysis.
Petrelli, a presenter the release associates with Demotech, Inc., said the 10 carriers cut total operating expenses to track changes in revenue. Insurance and claim costs were the exception: they grew faster than both revenue and other expenses. Demotech, which supported the event, says this matches its review of commercial automobile insurance results.
Insurance spending rose despite telematics and other risk management
Petrelli concluded that expense control alone did not protect margins. Telematics and other risk management efforts did not stop insurance costs from rising over the period. He said managing insurance and claim costs will be key to profitability for trucking companies in slower-growth environments.
For insurers, the same data point to litigation as a shared problem. Petrelli said litigation is a challenge for both insurers and truckers.
Demotech ties carrier failures to a 2022 surge in new litigation
Petrelli cited Demotech's 2022 postmortem on an "industrial scale" increase in new lawsuits that led to carrier failures. A separate Demotech research project, also in 2022, identified what it calls "tech-enabled litigation instigation." Demotech describes this as an online business model in which some plaintiff attorneys use artificial intelligence platforms, search engine optimization and pay-per-click advertising to redirect search traffic and secure contested claims.
Demotech says the model operates countrywide. It says the finding has prompted efforts to brief trade associations, legislators and regulators on policy changes to keep all lines of insurance available and affordable.
Regulators and carriers at the conference called for common data interpretation
The conference took place at the Grand Geneva Resort in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. Clayton W. Fisk, president and chief operating officer of the association, coordinated the program. David Heller, senior vice president of Safety and Government Affairs at the Truckload Carriers Association, gave the keynote. Winsome Lenfert, regional field administrator at the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), described how the agency supplies crash reduction studies and conducts motor carrier compliance reviews.
One theme ran through the presentations: regulators and the trucking industry need a common interpretation of the data and statistics regulators collect and publish. The release does not name the 10 carriers or give dollar figures for their insurance spending or revenue.