UNITED STATES -- November 19, 2026 -- The "tort tax," the cost of the legal system embedded in the premium every policyholder pays, might be as much as $5,000 per year, a panel told the National Association of Professional Insurance Agents (PIA) at its Annual Leadership Conference and Advocacy Day, held Sept. 13-16, 2026. In the next presentation, Demotech President Joseph L. Petrelli argued that the loss-cost formula insurers have used since the 1980s cannot isolate litigation cost, and that litigated claims will become more frequent.
The panel was moderated by Rick Keegan, executive vice president and enterprise chief underwriting officer at Travelers. It included Matthew E. Carlton of West Bend Insurance Company, Rhonda A. Hurwitz of the American Property Casualty Insurance Association and Glenn Westrick of Travelers. The consensus was that fraud, climate and weather changes, aging infrastructure and rising tort costs each add cost, in amounts that vary by line of business and jurisdiction. The material does not say who put forward the $5,000 figure or how it was calculated.
Petrelli says the loss-cost formula has no line for litigated claims
Advisory organizations, including Insurance Services Office, the National Council on Compensation Insurance and the American Association of Insurance Services, began issuing advisory loss costs instead of advisory premiums in the 1980s. Loss cost equals loss severity times loss frequency, or the average cost of claims per policy. Insurers then add expenses and a pre-tax profit provision. The formula has therefore been in use for more than 35 years, by our calculation.
It does not separate claims closed without payment, claims reported by the policyholder and settled, and claims litigated and settled. Petrelli proposes adding that granularity so insurers can put a number on the tort tax.
Demotech's review of industry aggregate Schedule P, Part 5 claim counts for commercial automobile liability at year-end 2025 found a pattern it calls "claim transitioning." It says the pattern conflicts with the assumptions built into the formula. Reported claim counts were relatively consistent across the ten year-ends from 2016 to 2025, except in the COVID years 2021 and 2022. The data come from National Association of Insurance Commissioners filings, consolidated by S&P Global, and neither organization endorses Demotech's conclusions.
Demotech traces a litigation-funding model to circa 2016, six years before its research
Demotech sponsored a 2022 research project that uncovered an online business model of tech-enabled litigation instigation. Petrelli says the model may have started circa 2016, about six years before the research, without the insurance sector's knowledge. He says several national law firms and early investors in third-party litigation funding (TPLF) knew of it, and that it has drawn billions in TPLF.
He lists eight developments he expects to raise litigation frequency, including alternative business structures (ABSs), management services organizations (MSOs), private equity and hedge fund capital, litigation marketing companies and AI-augmented law firms.
Four jurisdictions have modified ABA Rule 5.4 limits on nonlawyer ownership of law firms
ABA Model Rule 5.4(d) bars nonlawyers from owning any interest in a law practice, serving as a director or officer, and directing a lawyer's professional judgment. Arizona, Utah and the District of Columbia have modified the rule. Puerto Rico followed on Jan. 1, 2026. ABSs allow varying degrees of nonlawyer involvement.
In December 2024, the Association of Professional Responsibility Lawyers petitioned the American Bar Association to revise Rule 5.4. Petrelli is unaware of any ABA response. In April 2025, Lucian T. Pera of Adams & Reese, LLP published "The Playbook: How to Extend the Reach of an Arizona ABS Law Firm to the Entire United States."
Six to eight states enacted TPLF laws out of more than 20 legislative efforts
More than 20 legislative efforts to require TPLF disclosure or bar TPLF have been introduced in recent years, and six to eight states enacted laws. Taking 21 as the minimum number of efforts, the enactment rate is no more than about 29% to 38% (6 of 21 is 28.6%; 8 of 21 is 38.1%), by our calculation. A higher actual count of efforts would lower that share.
Petrelli says the insurance industry has not yet accounted for the changes in the legal profession in its effort to return litigation frequency to historical levels. He believes interest in the MSO model grew in response to the disclosure efforts. An MSO is a separate company, hired by contract, that runs a law firm's non-legal back-office functions while attorneys keep control of legal practice. Petrelli notes that the MSO, not the law firm, decides whether to secure TPLF. An ABS, by contrast, is a single entity and would likely be subject to TPLF disclosures.