NEW CASTLE -- November 19, 2026 -- Demotech, Inc. president and co-founder Joseph L. Petrelli told the NAIC Northeast Zone meeting in New Castle, New Hampshire, held Sept. 1-4, 2026, that insurance loss costs should be broken down by claim outcome. The current presentation of loss costs rests on claim frequency multiplied by claim severity alone. Petrelli wants regulators to also track claims closed without payment, closed with payment, and outstanding.
New Hampshire Insurance Commissioner DJ Bettencourt, vice chair of the Northeast Zone, invited Petrelli to speak.
Petrelli says 10 years of claims data contradicts the constant-mix assumption
Petrelli said the frequency-times-severity approach implicitly assumes two shares stay stable over time: claims settled on a policyholder's presentation, and claims that are litigated. He presented 10 years of reported-claims data from a third-party vendor of NAIC financial statements. In his account, the data shows claims moving among the three categories, so the mix is not constant.
He calls this movement "claim transitioning", the relative percentage of claims closed without payment, closed with payment, or outstanding. He also raised the possible need to separate claims litigated by a policyholder from claims litigated by a policyholder using third-party litigation financing.
Separate trend rates would replace a single composite inflation rate
According to the presentation, the added detail would let regulators and legislators monitor three things: changes in the frequency of transitioning claims, shifts in the relative cost of each claim type, and whether each type has its own annual inflation rate. Those rates would then trend each component, instead of one composite rate that gives no information on the components of a loss cost.
The release does not disclose the transition percentages behind the 10-year finding.
The update builds on a March 2023 joint briefing from Demotech and 4WARN Inc. to the NAIC Market Regulation and Consumer Affairs (D) Committee in Louisville, Kentucky, chaired by Utah Commissioner Jon Pike. Petrelli presented in person and Kozikowski joined virtually. They described an online business model of technology-enabled claims instigation, which Demotech says it unearthed through a research project undertaken by Kozikowski. The model uses search engine optimization, pay-per-click advertising and litigation platforms, often financed by third-party litigation funders, and can produce litigation at industrial scale, according to the release. The September 2026 meeting came about 3.5 years after that briefing, by our calculation.
Petrelli's current research covers changes within the legal profession, advances in artificial intelligence litigation platforms, and large-scale financial backing of plaintiff law firms' litigation.
Bettencourt holds seven NAIC roles beyond his Northeast Zone post, including two chairmanships
Besides being Northeast Zone vice chair, Bettencourt chairs the Casualty Actuarial and Statistical Task Force and the Consumer Liaison Committee. He also sits on the Executive Committee, the Property and Casualty Insurance Committee, the Market Regulation and Consumer Affairs Committee, the Government Relations Leadership Council, and the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act Working Group.
Ten named New Hampshire Insurance Department staff hold NAIC task force or working group seats. By our calculation, that is 24 assignments: 13 for six senior leaders and 11 for four actuarial and technical staff. Ned Cataldo has four, covering reinsurance, financial stability, capital adequacy and invested assets. Jennifer Li has five, including Life RBC and Long-Term Care Actuarial. Christian Citarella has four, including the Big Data and Artificial Intelligence Working Group.