Demotech urges insurers to keep trade association dues in budgets

COLUMBUS -- November 19, 2026 -- Demotech, Inc. has urged insurers and associate members of insurance trade associations not to cut membership dues as budgets for the ensuing year are drawn up, according to a company statement dated August 31, 2026. President and co-founder Joseph L. Petrelli calls 2017 to 2026 the insurance sector's "Lost Decade," a span of ten calendar years counting both end years.

Demotech dates the underlying activity earlier. The Columbus, Ohio rating firm says an internal postmortem on carrier failures and a separate research project, both in 2022, found that from circa 2015 insurers and other "deep pockets" were targeted online. By our calculation, that start is about two years before Petrelli's Lost Decade begins and about 11 years before the statement. The stated aim of the targeting was to turn policyholder claims into contested or litigated ones.

Demotech says online advertising, AI and litigation marketers turn claims into disputes

Demotech calls the model "tech-enabled litigation instigation." It says the model combines sophisticated online advertising, artificial intelligence platforms and litigation marketing firms, sometimes funded by third-party investment. Petrelli says AI has increased its effectiveness exponentially. The statement includes no data from the 2022 research, so these are Demotech's findings and Petrelli's opinions rather than independently verified figures.

Petrelli also says billboard, TV and radio advertising can now undermine the industry's reputation, while the financial damage occurs online.

Sharon Romano Petrelli says billions in litigation funding are available

Vice president and co-founder Sharon Romano Petrelli says billions of dollars of third-party litigation funding are available to invest in more litigation. She says additional billions are readied to transform the legal profession through alternative business structures, managed services organizations and other means. In her view, member dues matter more now than before.

The appeal is aimed at insurers and associate members who pay dues. Petrelli says trade associations focused on industry reputation, fraud or legal system abuse are critical to restoring the industry's integrity and to attracting new talent.

Both the postmortem and the research project took place in 2022. In the same year, on July 11, Demotech registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission as a nationally recognized statistical rating organization in the class of ratings for insurance companies.

Published by:
fairsonline_team
Company
Target market(s)
News Type