UNITED STATES – November 14, 2026 -- A4A disputed five claims in a New York Times story on airline passenger rights in a statement dated October 9, 2026, one day after the article ran. The story, headlined "How the Trump Administration Is Eroding Airline Passengers' Rights," was published October 8, 2026. A4A says the paper left out context on cash compensation, ancillary fees, disruption rules, wheelchairs and family seating.
A4A puts the cost of a European-style compensation scheme at $5.2 billion a year
The largest figure in the statement comes from a 2024 InterVISTAS report, which A4A cites. It says a European-style compensation scheme in the U.S. could cost passengers $5.2 billion annually, and could reduce service and increase operational disruptions.
A4A says cash compensation was never a passenger right, so it could not have been "rolled back." The only step toward such a scheme was an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking announced by Sec. Buttigieg in October 2024. A4A says it never moved forward, which leaves it dormant for about two years by our calculation.
A4A says airlines already give automatic refunds when a passenger declines rebooking, whether or not the delay or cancellation was within the carrier's control. It adds that airlines reimburse food, transportation and lodging for cancellations and significant controllable delays.
A4A says nearly 20% of a ticket price is government taxes and fees
A4A defends the Duffy DOT rule requiring itemized ticket components in the same font size. It says the rule makes costs more transparent. It notes that carriers have had to include all taxes and fees in advertised fares since 2011.
On optional fees, A4A says the Biden DOT failed to establish that consumers cannot find ancillary fee information. It describes that rule as "deemed an illegal rulemaking by the courts." It says Alaska, American, Delta, JetBlue, Southwest and United show side-by-side fare-type comparisons, including bag fees, before purchase.
A4A says Congress ordered the disruption changes and the family seating rule is still open
On disruptions, A4A says the bipartisan 2024 FAA reauthorization instructed DOT to reassess causes of delays and cancellations. Before the change, it says, airlines were held responsible for events outside their control. Its examples are aircraft cleaning after a passenger death, medical emergencies, removal of unruly passengers, and wind shear or volcanic ash.
On seating, A4A says none of its passenger carriers charges to seat children next to parents. It says it supports Congress's adjacent-seating mandate but calls the Biden/Buttigieg rule too prescriptive. It disputes the Times claim that DOT "has dropped early-stage efforts" on the issue. A4A says that rulemaking is ongoing and recently moved to the next phase of government review. It did not say when the rule will be released.
A4A is also challenging the Biden/Buttigieg-era wheelchair rule. It says the rule would penalize airlines for events such as lightning striking a wheelchair on the tarmac, with fines of up to $75,000 per instance. Airlines would still pay for repairs regardless of cause, A4A says. The litigation is ongoing.